
What Does it Take to be a ‘Good Man’? Complicating the Connection Between Masculinity and Violence in South Sudan
Dr Heidi Riley, Kings College London XCEPT consultant and gender and armed conflict specialist, shares some of the findings from the programme’s Impact of Trauma survey in South Sudan ahead of an upcoming publication. She reflects on the question ‘What does it take to be a ‘good man’?’
Much of the work on masculinity, insecurity and conflict focuses on violence. While expectations and stereotypes of masculinity feature as a driver of violence in XCEPT’s research, the relationship is not straightforward. Unpacking the complexity of this relationship is crucial in determining opportunities for change, whilst also recognising diversity in masculinity and men’s engagement as peacemakers.
In South Sudan, the majority of interethnic violence is carried out by men and is associated with cattle and livestock. In our analysis of our qualitative interviews with Nuer populations from Akobo, Jonglei State and Toposa populations in Kapoeta, Eastern Equatoria State, we found that the connection between masculinity and participation in violence can be understood in three different ways. Two of these are intertwined with notions of responsibility, respect and obligation, while the third is defined as irrational.
The ‘provider masculinity’ and the ‘good man’: cattle raiding for survival
The association between male roles and being the provider is identified across multiple contexts. One of the questions the research team asked to both men and women interviewees was, ‘What makes a good man?’ Interview participants never described this as someone who engages in violence. Instead, the dominant response was centred around the ability to provide and protect one’s family, and second, as someone who is respectful to their family, community and neighbours. As one respondent explained, ‘Because he is the head of a family, a man should provide food and look after his family’s safety. This is a good man’.
Indeed, a good man was often described in interviews in distinctly anti-violent terms. For example, as someone who does not cause fights in the community, does not beat their children or wife and shows respect and level headedness. Although bravery and ability to fight were expressed as expectations of masculinity, they were not included in response to the question of what defines a good man.
However, in a context of food insecurity and competition over cattle ownership – which are central to pastoralist culture, representing a means of economic exchange, social status, cultural identity or means of subsistence – the picture becomes more blurred. In a context of extreme food insecurity due to protracted conflict and multiple climate shocks, it has become increasingly difficult to achieve the position of the good, respected, cattle-owning husband and father, without engaging in violent actions such as cattle raiding. As described by one respondent, “Many conflicts are caused by hunger because when you have nothing through which to support your children, you will decide to take someone’s cow or go anywhere to get food.”
Where a man cannot provide for his family, he is then exposed to experiencing shame through ridicule or mocking. One respondent told of how a man unable to provide will be considered:
This man will be named as a lazy. People will say if he would be a woman he would have gone mad. He will be insulted by his friends, and his age-mates [peer group] will say, “Why would you visit the home of a man who is lazy and cannot take care of his home?”
This reveals a strange paradox, whereby men are expected to demonstrate the responsibility of provision and good fatherhood, defined in non-violent terms. Yet, in conditions of insecurity, fulfilling these expectations may require participation in violent raiding. This makes violence both a means of meeting responsibilities and avoiding shame, as well as a contradiction of the moral expectations associated with being a good man.
Masculinity and responsibility to the community: retaliatory violence
The second dimension of the relationship between violence with masculinity drawn from the research is centred around responsibility to community, and manifests in retaliatory or compensatory violence. As noted by one respondent a good man is ‘one who loves his community and compares them as one’. Therefore, as inferred throughout interviews, if harm – either in the form of cattle raiding or direct violence or killing – has been imposed on a community member by another group, the men of fighting age are obligated to respond or participate in retaliatory actions.
The focus on responsibility and obligation to community is key here. For example, where a male respondent is asked if he would get involved in retaliations, the response is consistently strong, with statements such as ‘Yes we have to get involved’. Another explained, ‘Hey! I am man, I can’t sit or hide myself somewhere and let my community be killed, … it is my responsibility to defend my people and my community’.
Again, failure to respond leads to accusations of being ‘fearful’ and invites ridicule or social exclusion. As explained by one respondent, ‘People will mock him, say that he is fearing. That is why he doesn’t want to fight when the enemies are around. Nobody will listen to his advice’. Another described how, ‘If people are going for an attack on the Murle [another ethnic group] as retaliation, and I do not go, when they come back nobody will talk with me, they will say this guy is fearful’. This type of man is denied recognition as a ‘proper’ man, not even worthy of marriage – another important marker of male personhood or respect – ‘People will say that they are fearing to die, people will mock them so much and nobody will talk to them, they won’t be able to take girls [for marriage]’.
Our research (publication upcoming) shows that the risk of shame or social exclusion can have both material and social consequence, including ostracisation from family and community. Thus, shame acts as a driver of violence where there are few alternatives to fulfilling the masculine provider role.
Trauma response, alcohol and masculinity: shameful violence
The third form of violence emerges from a more inherently shameful starting point. This is violence without purpose, described as violence fuelled by alcohol or madness. While alcohol is also described as being taken to embolden an individual when carrying out retaliatory violence, it also relates to irrational violence.
Alcohol is very dangerous [..] When a person is drunk, you will be disrespected and anyone can beat you. In the village, alcohol has done so much damage. [A drunk person] can shoot a soldier or beat his wife over small issues.
For those that engage in alcohol-fuelled violence or are unable to rationalise violence due to psychological problems – often recognised as a being brought on through previous experiences of violence – they are referred to as ‘useless’ or ‘bad’. These are described as people who ‘don’t want to hear elders’ advice’. Those who ‘drink and will abuse anyone including elders’. They will lose respect and will become ‘useless’ in the community.
Dissenting voices and opportunities for change
Social and structural conditions clearly underpin the complex interplay between masculine expectations, community and individualised obligation, and the distinction between violence that commands respect and violence that brings shame. The possibility for dissension then remains hard to discern. Key areas that we will explore in forthcoming publications is the role of elders, as respected members of the community, in advising on alternative options to violence, and the role of fathers in advising sons to limit engagement in violence. This is not to overshadow the vital role of women in violence prevention initiatives and peace meetings. However, without alternative options for the acquisition of resources to fulfil the responsibilities as a provider or through change in structural conditions, expectations of masculinity are likely to remain a driver of violence.
With thanks to Anna Sebit for her valuable input.

This article is issued by the Cross-Border Conflict Evidence, Policy and Trends (XCEPT) research programme, funded by UK International Development. XCEPT brings together world-leading experts and local researchers to examine conflict-affected borderlands, how conflicts connect across borders, the intersection of climate stresses and conflict, and the drivers of violent and peaceful behaviour, to inform policies and programmes that support peace.
The views and opinions expressed in this document are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent those of the UK government.